Jul 7, 2015

How do you think Eminem could of made MMLP2 worth the title The Marshall Mathers LP 2 ?

What Songs would you keep/lose ? Who would you want to produce it ? or keep Rick producing it.
Who do you want to feature on it and what are some songs that didnt make it (Symphony in H) that could be on the it

Personally i think if he kept these songs





What would you change ? completely change it or keep it the same and also i think Groundhog Day should be on the main tracklist.

 

Jul 7, 2015

Groundhog day , Don't Front, bezerk, and baby. Along with the ones you posted.

Edit: And f--- rick rubin, he can do Bezerk thats it.

 

Jul 7, 2015

It's impossible for it to be a worthy follow up. But -

1.Bad Guy
2.Parking Lot
3.Rhyme Or Reason
4.Baby
5.Groundhog Day
6.Berzerk
7.Love Game
8.Rap God
9.Brainless
10.Beautiful Pain
11.Headlights
12.Don't Front
13.Evil Twin

 

Jul 7, 2015

Take out So Much Better, Rhyme Or Reason, So Far..., Love Game, Survival, and a------. Add Groundhog Day and Baby to the official track list. Fill the rest with songs that got cut hoping that they are better than what he chose to put on there.

 

Jul 7, 2015

i'd scrap off headlights, legacy could be nice with a darker and non-pop beat, change the beat in so far, scrap off the monster, stronger than I was , desperation, survival

Id keep, bad guy, rhyme or reason i guess, somuch better, rap god, berzerk, evil twin, brainless, wicked ways, beautiful, groundhog day, baby
I like love game but could be nicer with an 'underground' beat,
about a------, maybe put some melody in the beat and put em singing the hook. in fact, he should sing all the hooks. Im fine the the hook on love game

Its nice that em's more mature but I guess we'd prefer a Kim-like song instead of stronger than I was

 

Jul 7, 2015

this song is f---ing dope

 

Jul 7, 2015

It's good. I wouldn't mind if it showed up on the bonus disc instead.

 

Jul 7, 2015

If he had made it in 2001. Than it could have been a good follow up. Or in 2003.
He should have used Dre/Bass Brothers for production. I would keep Rubin for Bezerk because I like that song.
1. Public Service Announcement
2. (k--- You/My Name Is Type song)
3. Bad Guy
4. Parking Lot (Skit)
5. Rhyme Or Reason
6. Legacy
7. Don't Front
8. Bezerk
9. (Rage filled track akin to Marshall Mathers or Amity Ville)
10. Rap God
11. Brainless
12. Groundhog Day
13. Beautiful Pain
14. Baby
15. Head Lights
16. Wicked Ways

Have Dre/Bass Brothers handle production and your golden. Maybe add in a few tracks similar to Drug Ballad/Marshall Mathers/Amity Ville/.
And for most of those songs his old flow (TES/SSLP/MMLP) would have made them better. Also, I know Fine Line probably wasn't recorded at that time but I like it so I put it on there. Plus it makes sense to be put before Rap God which caused some controversy. Really None of these songs lived up to the amazing opener that was Bad Guy. Gives me a similar feeling to Encore. Great opener but album doesn't live up to the hype. If we had gotten the public service announcement skit, a song on the level of and similar to k--- You and than Bad Guy, It would have been GODLY. Also, Guts Over Fear would have been a great closer. Also he should have dissed people. Diss rappers, diss pop stars. The whole shabang.

 

Jul 7, 2015

What If he had done k--- You 2?
"They say I can't rap about doin drugs no more/ They ain't say I can't rap about murder no more!"

 

Jul 7, 2015

Dr. Dre+Bass Brothers production would've done wonders to the album. That's Em's signature sound. Also get rid of Monster, Survival, So Much Better. Replace them with Groundhog Day, Beautiful Pain, Baby

 

Jul 7, 2015

I'd completely change it, have himself or Dr.Dre produce it and no chick hooks.

 

Jul 7, 2015

this
1. Bad Guy
2. Rhyme or Reason
3. Baby
4. Groundhog Day
5. Berzerk
6. Rap God
7. Brainless
8. Phenomenal
9. Guts Over Fear
10. Fine Line
11. Headlights
12. Kings Never Die

 

Jul 7, 2015

If there was any chance for Eminem to have created the perfect sequel he should have brought back the Bass Brothers, DJ Head and got Dre heavily involved on the project

There were also certain songs on Relapse that would have suited the MMLP 2 (Hello, My Darling, Deja Vu)

 

Jul 7, 2015

I don't think he got the vibe right. I have no problems with mmlp2 it's decent to good, it just lacks structure and has very few things in common with the first. It's hardly related outside the nostalgia factor

 

Jul 7, 2015

I think if he kept the theme going for the first 2 songs and skit of continuing the last mathers lp (bad guy-Stan, parking lot, ror- criminal) it would have been much better and more cohesive. Also having pop/rock songs with people like Rihanna and Skylar grey make no sense. And also like others have said, dre/bass brothers production would've helped tremendously. So basically:
1. Bad guy
2. Parking lot
3. Rhyme or reason
4. So much better
5. Groundhog Day
6. Legacy
7. Baby
8. Rap god
9. Brainless
10. Berserk
11. Don't front
12. Beautiful pain (could've replaced the monster as the radio single)
13. Wicked ways
14. Love game
15. Headlights
16. b---- please 3 ft xzibit, dr dre, snoop, and kendrick lamar
17. Evil twin

 

Jul 7, 2015

take out Headlights a------ Survival etc and add The Flood, Tales from the Script and Coming Down

 

Jul 7, 2015

Epic idea! Why has this specific scenario never been discussed before??

 

Jul 7, 2015

1. Bad Guy
2. Parking Lot (Skit)
3. Rhyme or Reason
4. So Much Better
5. Groundhog Day
6. Legacy
7. Baby
8. Rap God
9. Brainless
10. Berzerk
11. Don't Front
12. Beautiful Pain (feat. Sia)
13. Love Game (feat. Kendrick Lamar)
14. Evil Twin
15. Wicked Ways (feat. X Ambassadors)
Bonus Tracks:
16. Symphony In H [Extended]
17. Survival
18. So Far...
19. Fine Line