Sep 2, 2018No joke. I truly think this album might get classic status in few months. I dont think ppl giving good guy the credit it deserves
-
Cynic, Alchemistindakitchen, Jimelej and 11 others like this.Jun 8, 2026
-
Jun 8, 2026
Sep 2, 2018
knock knock let the devil in -
Jun 8, 2026
Sep 2, 2018

-
Jun 8, 2026
Sep 1, 2018
Tbf, anyone hating on this album is either deaf or just f---in stupidVR46, IDKENGLISH, knightsoftomorrow and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
@Michael Myers 3.0
Here are my thoughts-
(First tbh u should’ve made this a thread asking for my opinion) ...but I like it! Here are the posters who I mostly agree with: @JFK @Swizz @Jet✞ @Big Cuntry. Co-sign a lot of their thoughts. As @Worm said most everyone else is trying too hard to hate it, or just stans. That leaves ME and few others to give this an honest take.
The Ringer. Great opener. One of the best beats he’s rapped on it in a minute and immediately put me at ease. “He,” I thought to myself while walking my dog “has righted the ship.” Just really fun and confident. Vintage a------ energy heh
Greatest: woof that chorus lol. Almost details it for me but I still like it. (Its encore level bad chorus so I stan wash it away). Good generally. I should be paid to pontificate on Pitchfork. I could do it hold on I’m quitting my real job
Lucky You: good! Tbh Joyner Lucas is whatever. I dig em’s honesty and def awareness
Skits: enjoyable
Normal: ahhhhhh ehhhhh. Generic relationship stuff no thanks. At this point it’s pure fiction or too watered down to rly resonate. It’s not embarrassing (that’s the bar) or even awk. I probably won’t listen much after my nerves have settled
Stepping stone: GREAT! Even better than castle/arose. It’s almost deja vu no apologies level - vintage personal eminem. How does he manage songs like this out of nowhere? Even the beat sounds classic em if that makes sense. As jfk said I’m invested in the “story” of eminem and this was amazing and heartfelt fan service. A song about d12 working in 2018? This is the kind of stuff you won’t read about in POW but it’s true
Not Alike: some lines work, I like the chorus I guess. Not rly into it?
Kamikaze: it’s dumb but I dig it. Harmless and silly. Double down on fack and almost make it work ok sure it’s 2018. What a goofball I like rap
Fall: pretty good. Dope hook. Nice flow and lyrics. As a white guy in his early 30s I’m drawn to anything Justin Vernon
Nice guy: ahhhhhhh no. “s--- my d-ck!” ruins it for me shout out @M Solo
Good guy: weird and boring. No thanks
Venom: not rly for me, but I hope the kids and r-----s out there like it. It’s whatever, crappy and kind of The Type Of song ostensibly the other tracks were lamenting but sure. So weird how bloated and toothless all these post Lose Yourself soundtrack/rock stadium “anthems” are
—-
So you see, it mostly works. It at least isn’t a slog/embarrassing. I know a lot of black people and rappers who agree with me. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
I had to hand pick like maybe 5 tracks from his last 4 releases (shady xv, southpaw, mmlp2, revival) to make an album that was not full of cringe. And out of all those there was hardly 12 excellent tracks. This one album is all solid. Haven't been this amped about listening to an eminem album since BME. Revival was so bad I've only heard it twice since its release. I've heard this one 5 times today! -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
Just finished my first listen and HOLY FUCKKKZ Gangsta, IDKENGLISH, shadyslim555 and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026Z Gangsta, IDKENGLISH, Cyreides and 11 others like this.
-
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
Em really gives zero f---s on this album.... So f---ing refreshingJMilliAMC16, Mudkip, IDKENGLISH and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
oh god
i got to venom and had a brief vietnam flashback to revival/recovery for a second

then the song 180'd after the intro
JMilliAMC16, Mudkip, IDKENGLISH and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
Nothing wrong with this for 2003 eminemJMilliAMC16, Mudkip, Z Gangsta and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
Wow kendrick has credits on greatest just cuz em copied him in one line
Em the goatJMilliAMC16, ShadyRedDevil, Mudkip and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
A 40+ year old Eminem did what hopsin has been trying to do his entire careeer (mock current rap trends) & executed it 10x better than he ever would have lmao.JMilliAMC16, Mudkip, IDKENGLISH and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
I love how he used venom as a teaser
"Oh hes about to drop another pop movie trailer anthem single"
Little did I knowJMilliAMC16, Mudkip, IDKENGLISH and 11 others like this. -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
i'm....not going to sleep tonight.JMilliAMC16, Z Gangsta, Mudkip and 11 others like this. -
Aug 31, 2018
Em right now
JMilliAMC16, Mudkip, Etari and 11 others like this.Jun 8, 2026 -
Aug 31, 2018
This rivals his best albums come @ meIceyMenace, JMilliAMC16, Z Gangsta and 11 others like this.Jun 8, 2026 -
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
Gotta be his best album since The Eminem Show right?? I don't think I'm overreacting?IceyMenace, JMilliAMC16, Z Gangsta and 11 others like this. - Jun 8, 2026
-
Jun 8, 2026
Aug 31, 2018
CHLORASPECTIC REMIX STARTED ALL OF THIS AND EMINEM CAME THROUGH
PROPSIceyMenace, Mudkip, afghaniStan and 11 others like this.
