Eminem Best Posts: A Stan's honest opinion..

  1. Immy
    Posts: 27,605
    Likes: 46,790
    Joined: Jul 26, 2015

    Immy yikes

    Dec 13, 2017
    Recovery is miles above this... like every song on recovery is listenable even songs like W.T.P and So Bad...
    MMLP2 was outstanding on the first listen but lacked replay value. We even thought it would be the 3rd or 4th.
    Relapse aged like fine wine and even then it had a solid basis this album is everywhere in a bad way.. the hooks are terrible (minus the ed sheeran one) the mixing is laughable, soundcloud level.


    This album... The flows are f---ing dreadful, its everywhere it's like the Shady XV song but x19 essentially. He really has forgot how to flow and how to make a good song and this could be forgiven BUT.. Lets look at the intro and the lead single to the album

    WALK ON WATER....
    I praised this song for Em's self-awareness and vulnerability. He admits he's not the man he once was but he's trying to reach them hights again. The delivery is raw and the song doesn't sound forced at all.. The ending sequence in the third verse was perfect and a tear jerker. He says in the song and i quote "Im trying not to ruin your expectations and meet them" then addresses songs where we are critical of his shouting etc. What does he then do to follow up from this song? Release 18 other songs that literally ruin the "Legacy, love and respect" he took so long to garner. Every song is f---ing whack, Castle is the best song and thats disjointed and mixed poorly.


    Hopsin released a better project than Eminem in
    XXXTentacion released a project better than Eminem let that sink in....
    G-EAZY released a better project than Eminem
    All you lyrical miracle f--s are stupid if you think this album is anything close to any Future or Thugger project cos it really isnt.

    This is literally the worst album hes ever made and possibly the worst album ive heard in a long a--- time..

    I've skipped 4 f---ing songs and i dont even remember what songs they were.

    Rick rubin is a cuck
    Dr Dre is a cuck
    Eminem is a cuck
    Paul Rosenberg is a cuck

    EVEN songs like Wee Wee and Fack are better put together than every song on this album but Walk on water.

    BY FAR his worst album
     
    Mar 21, 2026
  2. gdot
    Posts: 1,192
    Likes: 3,044
    Joined: Mar 2, 2011

    Dec 13, 2017

    You already made a thread.
    You don’t like it. We got it.

    You made that clear with your first thread ten minutes ago
     
    #2
    3
    Knox, Tarre86 and Mr Iglesias like this.
    3
    Knox, Tarre86 and Mr Iglesias like this.
    Mar 21, 2026