Jul 3, 2025 at 4:22 PM

It is, but that's cause this one flopped also but quality wise, it's gonna go all the way up

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 4:27 PM

It doesn’t matter if we watched the same show. If you can’t explain your issues with something then you probably shouldn’t be critiquing it as if you are some sort of expert who is always right no matter what.

Nope! This season is going to flop even harder because the majority of the audience does not give a s--- about Abby’s backstory and Neil left so the game creator isn’t even involved anymore. People were worried about season 3 flopping because of Abby’s backstory before season 2 even came out. If you think the quality is gonna go up now that Neil is gone you are delusional. Hope this helps! You just have a crush on Kaitlyn Dever, that’s the only reason you think any of this lmao

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 4:36 PM

That's cause 1 the show s----d so far and 2 the ones that know the story, a bunch of them hates TLOU2 which is pretty stupid cause it's a great game.

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 7:28 PM

HBO f----- up by not changing the season 2 storyline. Whether it was Druckmann or whoever, this isn't the type of show where you k--- off the main character. It's not GOT. I know the game pt 2 is more critically acclaimed, but as a show they had to know it wasn't going to work. The first game was perfect for TV and what they added to it (much better story imo as well), like the Frank and Bill episode only made it better. Them splitting the season up between the Abby and Ellie story like the game was a really weird move. Not sure if they're scrapping that idea and Druckmann got pissy about it, or he's really just stepping away to actually focus on the games

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 7:36 PM

Actually Mazins been the main writer as well for both seasons. Maybe Druckmann isn't the issue and after this season flopped and he saw the plans for 3 he walked away. What a clusterfuck

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 7:37 PM

Honestly they probably should’ve just had Ellie’s and Abby’s stories play out at the same time instead of doing them in separate seasons. They already lost a lot of viewers, but now they’re gonna lose a ton more. I imagine the way a lot of casual viewers watching the show see it is “Abby just killed off a character I loved. Why would I care to tune into a season all about her?” Even though Kaitlyn Dever is a good actress, I don’t think that’s going to save it. They’ve already shot themselves in the foot

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 7:38 PM

I think Mazin was behind a lot of the stupid changes in season 2, like making Ellie a dumbass. I could be wrong though

 

Jul 3, 2025 at 7:39 PM

YES. This is exactly what I said when the season started. I was like, there's no way they will split up the seasons like the game. They will definitely combine them. It worked great for the game but you can't do that for a show, especially after an emotional episode like 2 where you take out the main character. I mean I'm still going to watch it regardless since I played the games to see where they go with it, but they really dropped the ball