Oct 20, 2024I just see anywhere in the 6’s as above average, since 5 is what I consider average, and it just kinda shocked me to see a 6.5 for the album considering a lot of people consider this album to be towards the realm of an 8-10. Wasn’t trying to come at ya, just makes it fun to see what score I can get out of you!
-
-
Oct 20, 2024
In the realm of music and movies a score of 6.5 is solid. Movies that get an 8 or above are usually all time classics.
I don’t believe in giving out 10/10s even for my favorite albums. More often than not, there’s at least one song that falls flat. For example, I’d probably rate TES around a 9.7 even though it’s likely my number one album of all time.
Here's a breakdown according to ChatGPT.
Sure! Here’s a breakdown of music scores on a scale from 1 to 10:
1 - Poor
Characteristics: Disorganized, lacks melody, and rhythm. Instruments may clash and vocals are off-key.
Impact: Unpleasant to listen to, often feels unfinished or careless.
2 - Fair
Characteristics: Some semblance of structure but still heavily flawed. Few interesting moments, with major issues in execution.
Impact: Can be grating; may only appeal to very niche audiences.
3 - Mediocre
Characteristics: Basic ideas present, but lacking depth. Simple melodies and predictable progressions.
Impact: Forgettable; not engaging enough to warrant repeated listening.
4 - Decent
Characteristics: More cohesive than mediocre but still shows significant weaknesses in composition and performance.
Impact: Some enjoyable moments, but overall lacks polish.
5 - Average
Characteristics: Competent but unremarkable. Standard song structures and familiar themes without unique twists.
Impact: Can be enjoyable in the background but doesn’t stand out.
6 - Good
Characteristics: Solid craftsmanship with catchy hooks and competent instrumentation. A few standout moments or clever ideas.
Impact: Likely to be enjoyed by a wider audience, though may not be memorable in the long run.
7 - Very Good
Characteristics: Strong melodies and well-executed arrangements. Displays creativity and emotional resonance.
Impact: Likely to be revisited; resonates well with listeners.
8 - Excellent
Characteristics: High level of artistry, innovative concepts, and emotional depth. Great production quality and skilled performances.
Impact: Memorable and impactful; stands out in its genre.
9 - Exceptional
Characteristics: Masterful composition and execution. Unique sound, profound lyrics, and emotional connection that transcends typical boundaries.
Impact: Leaves a lasting impression and can influence others; often considered a classic.
10 - Masterpiece
Characteristics: A pinnacle of artistic achievement. Flawless integration of all elements—melody, harmony, rhythm, lyrics, and production.
Impact: Timeless quality; often cited as a benchmark in music history, inspiring generations.
I think 6.5 for an album I will never listen to again, not even for one song is a fair score. Don't make me hit you in the head with a participation trophyOrdinary Joel, Justin Trudeau, jankland and 2 others like this. -
Oct 20, 2024
Ordinary Joel, jankland, Yeez and 2 others like this.(This ad goes away when signing up) -
-
Ordinary Joel, jankland, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this.
-
Ordinary Joel, jankland, Yeez and 2 others like this.
-
Oct 19, 2024
Ordinary Joel, jankland, Justin Trudeau and 2 others like this. -
Oct 18, 2024
jankland, Ordinary Joel, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this. -
Oct 18, 2024
jankland, Ordinary Joel, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this. -
Oct 18, 2024
jankland, Ordinary Joel, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this. -
Oct 14, 2024
jankland, Ordinary Joel, Yeez and 2 others like this. -
Oct 13, 2024
Excited for this, great pick.Justin Trudeau, Ordinary Joel, jankland and 2 others like this. -
Oct 7, 2024
jankland, Yeez, Justin Trudeau and 2 others like this. -
Oct 7, 2024
It would be a really good bit to do every album in atmosphere's catalog back to backClick to expand...Ordinary Joel, Jimmy Jazz, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this.(This ad goes away when signing up) -
Oct 7, 2024
Gonna hack into the SX80 mainframe and delete random accounts from this club so I can get my next pick in soonerClick to expand...
1. The Offspring - Americana - 8.7
2. Big K.R.I.T. - 4Eva is a Mighty Long Time - 8.5
3. Bring Me The Horizon - Post Human: Survival Horror - 8.0
4. Marilyn Manson - Eat Me, Drink Me - 7.8
5. Three 6 Mafia - Smoke clears: Sixty 6, Sixty 1 - 7.5
6. Hermit and the Recluse - ORPHEUS vs. The Sirens - 7.5
7. Ice Cube - Laugh Now, Cry Later - 7.5
8. Lil Jon & The Eastside Boyz - Kings of Crunk - 7.5
9. Atmosphere - When Life Gives You Lemons, You Paint That s--- Gold - 7.3
10. J Hus - Big Conspiracy - 7.2
11. Isaiah Rashad - Clivia Demo – 7
12. Travis Scott - Rodeo 6.5
13. Eminem - The Death of Slim Shady - 6
14. Paris Texas - Mid Air - 6
15. The Weeknd - House of Balloons - 5.5
16. Lorde - Melodrama - 5
17. Bright Eyes - Lifted or The Story Is in the Soil - 5
18. JPEGMAFIA - All My Heroes Are Cornballs – 3
Average Score: 6.75
Ordinary Joel, Justin Trudeau, Yeez and 2 others like this. -
Oct 7, 2024
Gonna hack into the SX80 mainframe and delete random accounts from this club so I can get my next pick in soonerClick to expand...Jimmy Jazz, Ordinary Joel, Yeez and 2 others like this. -
Oct 7, 2024
first couple listens I thought it was like a 5/10 but it grew on me a ton, I think learning some of the lore s--- weirdly helped the original problems I had with the mixing on that record. Its just annoying when Survival Horror is mixed and mastered immaculatelyClick to expand...
Not that I’m saying I need something mega polished from the band, it’s just that I felt like they went two steps back with that release in terms of how it sounded.Ordinary Joel, Justin Trudeau, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this. -
Oct 6, 2024
I think having Metal freaks, Rap freaks and Pop freaks in the rotation of users is going to keep this thread pretty fun for a while if it stays somewhat active!Click to expand...Ordinary Joel, jankland, Jimmy Jazz and 2 others like this.(This ad goes away when signing up) -
Oct 6, 2024
Oh h--- yeah Seether, we've had a severe lack of divorced dad musicClick to expand...Ordinary Joel, Yeez, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this.(This ad goes away when signing up) -
Oct 6, 2024
Click to expand...Ordinary Joel, Yeez, DiggleDogg69 and 2 others like this.