Nov 16, 2015 That's why I named MMLP too. The Eminem Show sounds perfect to me both lyrically and musically but anyway. Say What You Say wasn't a classic but it was good. Eminem used to sound the best. Same for Superman. Rap is not just lyrics. It's also delivery, the flow, the music and Eminem in his prime was ahead of Jay in terms of those. One other rapper I can say that is on par with Em on flow s--- is Biggie. I don't see how The Eminem Show has dated production ? I'd take that production to most of the production today in hip hop music.
Nov 16, 2015 I didn't say or have ever said the album was trash. Objectively it's not great and I think if you made a poll most people would agree with me.
Nov 16, 2015 i would love to see a forum label TPAB as not great, but it wont happen every review you can find on the internet either says its amazing or it was pretty good. and arent you the guy who thinks drake is the best rapper ever? lol he dosent even write his lyrics
Nov 16, 2015 LOL when you put it like that it sounds like you're right but it's not just ordinary s---. I mean thing Em have gone thru and the crazy ways he Express his feelings etc... Anyway, guess we agree on both Em & Jay are the goats and their place on that list are very well-deserved.
Nov 16, 2015 There are so many things wrong with this list: Lauren Hill <<< Jay Z #2<<<< No Travis Scott <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
Nov 16, 2015 To p---- A Butterfly is a bit overrated s---. It doesn't have much replay value. There some classic s--- but also some boring s--- that you might not be able to get into easily.
Nov 16, 2015 I'm saying it's overrated by many. It's a good album but no way it can be defined as a classic.
Nov 16, 2015 There's a difference between somebody being your favorite vs thinking they're the best out. Perfect example being D Rose.
Nov 16, 2015 You shouldn't have relate to something to be able to be judge it objectively. You're allowed to like all 3 Eminem albums more if you want, but by most objective measures RD is clearly better
Nov 16, 2015 -No Kanye, but he has 6 out of 6 classics -Eminem even tho, at MOST, he has 3 out of like 7 or 8 or whatever # he's on -Kendrick for some f---ing reason Lmao
Nov 16, 2015 no it's not. I already gave my reasons. No matter how much you try to be objective it's the music in the end. I'm not gonna sit there and give reasons again.
